The Forex Brokers That Collapsed After the Swiss Franc Shock
When the Swiss franc jumped on 15 January 2015, clients' losses ran past their deposits and several brokers could not absorb them. Alpari UK went under, FXCM needed a $300 million rescue, and the industry's rules changed. Here is what happened to each.
The Swiss National Bank's decision to scrap its euro floor on 15 January 2015 bankrupted or nearly bankrupted several retail forex brokers, because their clients' losses were larger than the money in their accounts. Alpari UK declared insolvency the next day. FXCM, then one of the biggest US brokers, reported about $225 million of client negative balances and needed a $300 million loan to survive.
New Zealand's Global Brokers closed. Other brokers and banks reported losses but carried on.
The episode is the clearest lesson in why the strength of your broker, and the protections attached to your account, matter as much as spreads and platforms.
| Event | SNB removes EUR/CHF 1.20 floor, 15 January 2015 |
|---|---|
| Alpari UK | Insolvent on 16 January, then special administration |
| FXCM | About $225m of client negative balances; $300m rescue loan |
| Global Brokers NZ | Closed |
| Lasting change | Negative balance protection made mandatory in the EU from 2018 |
Why brokers were exposed
Many retail brokers pass client trades on to banks or liquidity providers. If a client loses more than their deposit, the broker still owes the bank, and must try to collect the shortfall from the client. On 15 January the franc moved so far, so fast, that thousands of clients holding leveraged short-franc positions ended the day with negative balances. Brokers had to pay their banks immediately but had little hope of collecting from clients quickly, if ever.
Alpari UK
Alpari UK, the London arm of a well-known broker group, said on 16 January that most clients had been on the right side of the move, but those on the wrong side had suffered losses beyond their equity, and those losses had passed to the firm. It declared insolvency and, after failing to find a buyer, entered special administration. Because UK rules required client money to be held in segregated accounts, the administrators were able to return client funds, although the process took time.
FXCM
FXCM, listed on the New York Stock Exchange, said client accounts owed it about $225 million, which pushed it below its regulatory capital requirements. Within days it agreed a $300 million emergency loan from Leucadia National, on terms that gave the lender a large share of future proceeds. Its share price collapsed.
Its troubles did not end there. In February 2017 the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission fined FXCM $7 million, finding it had misrepresented how it executed client trades, and the firm withdrew from the US market. A separate settlement related to claims about negative balance protection. FXCM continued to operate outside the US under new ownership.
The others
- Global Brokers NZ said the franc's surge had made it impossible to continue and closed.
- IG, the large UK broker, survived comfortably; its losses were estimated at no more than about £30 million, partly money it hoped to recover from clients. It later repaid some clients after Financial Ombudsman rulings.
- Banks and other brokers in several countries reported losses of varying size, and some clients disputed whether they owed negative balances at all.
What happened to clients
For clients, the outcome depended on which side of the trade they were on and where their account was held. Those long the franc made unexpected profits, though some found their brokers slow to pay or, in the worst cases, unable to. Clients short the franc faced losses far beyond the stop-loss levels they had set, and many received demands to repay negative balances.
Responses varied by broker. Some firms quickly forgave negative balances for retail clients to protect their reputations. Others pursued clients for the money, leading to complaints, legal disputes and Financial Ombudsman cases in the UK. A few brokers argued that trades filled at extreme prices in the chaos should be cancelled or repriced, which caused further disputes over whether profits or losses on those fills were valid.
The experience taught many retail traders a lesson they had not considered: the stop-loss order they relied on did not cap their risk, and the broker they chose for its low spreads had its own financial limits. Both points now feature prominently in regulators' warnings to retail clients.
What changed for traders
Regulators moved to make sure clients could not owe brokers more than they deposited. The European Securities and Markets Authority made negative balance protection mandatory for retail contract for difference (CFD) clients across the EU from 2018, alongside leverage limits of 30:1 on major currency pairs, and the UK's Financial Conduct Authority adopted the same rules. Many brokers elsewhere began offering negative balance protection voluntarily as a selling point.
Brokers also changed their own risk management. Many raised margin requirements on pegged or heavily managed currencies, limited leverage before big events, and stress-tested what would happen if a currency moved 20% or more in minutes.
Mark held his trading account at a small broker offering 400:1 leverage because spreads were slightly cheaper. When the franc jumped he had no open position, but a colleague with a short-franc trade at the same broker lost far more than his deposit and received a demand for payment. Mark realised his own money depended on the broker's ability to survive other clients' losses, and moved his account to a firm regulated by the FCA with negative balance protection and segregated client funds.
Client money rules and compensation schemes differ by country and by the company that holds your account. Check exactly which entity your agreement is with, and what protection that entity's regulator gives, before you deposit.
Lessons
- Your broker is a counterparty. Its survival can affect your money, even if you did nothing wrong.
- Negative balance protection matters. It limits your losses to your deposit on a gap.
- Segregated client money helps when a broker fails, but recovery can still take months.
- Cheap is not always better. A slightly wider spread at a stronger broker can be worth it.
Learn how to check a broker before you deposit in how to identify the best forex broker, and read the full market story in the Swiss franc crash of 2015.
Cite this guide
FX Recap, "The Forex Brokers That Collapsed After the Swiss Franc Shock", updated 16 November 2026, https://fxrecap.com/learn-forex/education/brokers-that-collapsed-swiss-franc
Free to quote with a link. Journalists: data and comment in our press room.
Frequently asked
Which forex brokers went bust after the Swiss franc shock?
Alpari UK declared insolvency on 16 January 2015 and entered special administration, and Global Brokers NZ closed. FXCM survived only after a $300 million rescue loan. Several other brokers and banks reported losses but continued operating.
Why did the Swiss franc shock bankrupt brokers?
The franc jumped so far, so fast, that many clients' losses exceeded their deposits. Brokers had to cover those losses with their banks immediately but could not collect the shortfall from clients, which wiped out the capital of weaker firms.
What happened to FXCM after 2015?
It reported about $225 million of client negative balances and took a $300 million loan from Leucadia National. In 2017 the CFTC fined it $7 million over how it represented its trade execution, and it withdrew from the US market. It continued outside the US under new ownership.
Did Alpari UK clients get their money back?
Client money was held in segregated accounts under UK rules, so administrators were able to return client funds, although the process took time. Clients with negative balances faced claims for the amounts they owed.
What is negative balance protection?
A guarantee that you cannot lose more than the money in your trading account. If a gap pushes your account below zero, the broker writes off the negative balance. It has been mandatory for retail CFD clients in the EU and UK since 2018.
How can I tell if my broker is safe?
Check that it is licensed by a strong regulator, holds client money in segregated accounts, offers negative balance protection and publishes financial information. Confirm which company holds your account, because protections depend on that entity.
Related reading
The team behind this guide
Researched, checked and approved by five forex specialists
Every guide is written, fact-checked and edited before it goes live, and updated when the facts change. Spotted an error? Tell us.










