IC Markets
After USD/ZAR, the rand crosses South African traders look at most are GBP/ZAR and EUR/ZAR. They are tradeable, and some traders prefer them for specific reasons, but they come with costs and complications that USD/ZAR does not. This guide covers how they behave and when they make sense.
How the crosses are built
GBP/ZAR and EUR/ZAR are effectively combinations of two other rates. EUR/ZAR moves with both EUR/USD and USD/ZAR. So the pair reacts to euro-area news (ECB decisions, euro-zone inflation) and to everything that moves the rand, at the same time. That is more to watch, and it means the pair can move sharply on news from a region you were not following.
The costs are higher
| Pair | Typical spread | Overnight swap | Liquidity |
|---|---|---|---|
| USD/ZAR | Widest of the majors, but manageable | Meaningful | Good |
| GBP/ZAR | Wider than USD/ZAR | Larger | Thinner |
| EUR/ZAR | Wider than USD/ZAR | Larger | Thinner |
The wider spread is a cost on every trade, and the larger swap is a cost on every night held. For an active trader that adds up. The thinner liquidity also means more slippage around news and in the quiet hours.
When a cross makes sense
- You have a specific view on the pound or euro that you want to express with rand as the other leg, for example around a Bank of England or ECB decision.
- You are hedging a real exposure, such as GBP income or EUR expenses, rather than pure speculation.
- Your strategy has a genuine edge on GBP/ZAR or EUR/ZAR levels specifically, backed by testing, not just a preference for the pair.
Why USD/ZAR is usually better
For most South African retail traders, USD/ZAR is the better rand pair: tighter spread, smaller swap, deeper liquidity, and one dominant driver set to follow (the dollar and the rand) rather than two. If your interest is simply trading the rand, trade it against the dollar. The crosses are for when you specifically want the pound or euro leg. Our USD/ZAR guide covers the main pair.
Lerato traded EUR/ZAR because she found the levels 'cleaner' on the chart. Over two months she realised she was paying noticeably more in spread and swap than on USD/ZAR, and getting caught by euro-area news she did not track. She moved her rand trading to USD/ZAR and kept EUR/ZAR only for the occasional ECB-week trade where she had a euro view. Her costs dropped and her results improved with the same strategy.
The news you have to track doubles
On USD/ZAR, you follow the US calendar and the South African calendar. EUR/ZAR adds a third one: the ECB rate decision, euro-zone flash inflation, German data, and euro-group political news. GBP/ZAR instead adds the Bank of England, UK inflation and UK fiscal events. Either way it is a whole extra region of scheduled volatility landing on your position, often at hours you were not watching. A trader who only really follows the US and South Africa will be surprised by EUR/ZAR moves that had an obvious euro-area cause.
| Pair | Calendars to follow |
|---|---|
| USD/ZAR | US (Fed, CPI, jobs) and South Africa (SARB, CPI, Budget) |
| EUR/ZAR | US, South Africa, and the euro area (ECB, euro-zone CPI, German data) |
| GBP/ZAR | US, South Africa, and the UK (BoE, UK CPI, UK fiscal events) |
Swap costs on the crosses
Holding a rand cross overnight usually costs more in swap than holding USD/ZAR, because the interest-rate maths runs through a less liquid pair and brokers price the financing wider. A day trader who is flat by the evening rollover is unaffected. For a swing trader holding for days, the accumulated swap on GBP/ZAR or EUR/ZAR can quietly eat a meaningful share of the trade's profit. Check the swap rate for your pair and holding period before you assume the cross is equivalent to USD/ZAR.
GBP/ZAR and EUR/ZAR combine the rand's volatility with a second currency's news flow, at a wider spread and a larger swap. Trade them only when you specifically want that second leg, not as a default rand pair.
The rand crosses are a specialist tool. If a trader tells me they trade EUR/ZAR because they like the chart, I steer them to USD/ZAR, which is cheaper and simpler to follow. Save the crosses for the weeks when you have a real view on the pound or the euro.
Frequently asked
What drives GBP/ZAR and EUR/ZAR?
Both the rand's drivers and the second currency's. EUR/ZAR reacts to ECB decisions and euro-zone data as well as everything that moves the rand, so the pair can move sharply on news from either region.
Are the rand crosses more expensive to trade than USD/ZAR?
Yes. GBP/ZAR and EUR/ZAR have wider spreads, larger overnight swaps and thinner liquidity than USD/ZAR, which adds cost on every trade and every night held.
When should I trade GBP/ZAR or EUR/ZAR instead of USD/ZAR?
When you have a specific view on the pound or euro you want to express against the rand, when you are hedging a real GBP or EUR exposure, or when your tested strategy has an edge on those pairs specifically.
Which rand pair is best for beginners?
USD/ZAR. It has the tightest spread, smallest swap and deepest liquidity of the rand pairs, and one main driver set to follow rather than two.
Can I hedge pound income with GBP/ZAR?
You can use GBP/ZAR to hedge a real exposure such as GBP income against rand expenses, but understand the spread and swap costs and treat it as risk management rather than a profit trade.